Four related events led to the founding of UCC PIN in 2012:
1. In 2005 General Synod 25 passed the “Use of Economic Leverage in Promoting Peace in the Middle East. Among other things, the resolution called on the church to challenge the practices of corporations that gain from the continuation of the conflict and to divest from those companies that refuse to change their practices of gain from the perpetuation of violence, including the Occupation.
2. That same year Palestinian civil society initiated the BDS movement, calling for boycotts, divestment and sanctions as a form of non-violent pressure on Israel.
3. During this period, Gay Harter and Rev. Branwen Cook had organized a Task Force on Israel Palestine in the Massachusetts conference.
4. Leading up to the 2011 General Synod 28, Rev. Cook learned that a group of delegates planned to introduce a resolution that would encourage positive investment in Palestine while committing the UCC to refrain from engaging in BDS activities. The group was composed of people who had visited Israel/Palestine on trips funded by Christians for Fair Witness in the Middle East. Because the proposal was in contradiction to the Kairos Palestine document and the church’s policy in many other areas, the MA Task Force
organized to educate and inform GS28 delegates about the resolution’s problems. The Synod Committee recommended “No Action”; the principal proposer withdrew the Resolution. This experience convinced Gay and Branwen, who as a GS28 delegate had been instrumental in
informing the other delegates, that the UCC needed a national grass-roots organization to educate and organize the church around support for resolutions already passed, to develop new initiatives to promote justice for Palestinians, and to support Global Ministries partners in
Palestine and Israel.
2012
January – Eleven activists from UCC congregations and institutions from around the country along with support staff from Wider Church Ministries (Jim Moos, Peter Makari, Derek Duncan) and Justice and Witness Ministries (Mike Neuroth) held an organizational meeting in Cleveland. The group selected the name (UCC Palestine Israel Network) and chose Co-Chairs Gay Harter and Branwen Cook (who later resigned due to health issues.) The activists became UCC PIN’s Steering Committee, the PIN’s decision-making body with the staff persons functioning as non-voting resource persons.
Other 2012 actions and activities
PIN Presence in the UCC and among allied groups
workshop.
contacts with the Pension Boards, United Church Funds, and the Corporate Social
Responsibility Committee.
attended the campaign’s annual conference
2013 – A General Synod Year
January - At the Annual Meeting in Cleveland the steering committee met, assessed the work of 2012, and planned for the future. General Minister and President Geoffrey Black and Jim Moos, Executive Minister of Wider Church Ministries participated.
General Synod 29 in Long Beach, California
Other 2013 actions and activities
2014
February – At the Annual Meeting in Washington DC we focused on the GS30 resolution by working on the draft of the text and discussing strategy with Katherine Cunningham of IPMN.
Actions Related to the GS30 resolution
PIN Advocacy and Presence among allied groups
2015 - A General Synod Year
February – At the annual meeting in Cleveland we assessed the previous year and strategized on the campaign for passage of our resolution, titled “A CALL FOR THE UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST TO TAKE ACTIONS TOWARD A JUST PEACE IN THE ISRAELI-PALESTINIAN CONFLICT.”
Colleagues from PCUSA, UMKR, and JVP joined us offering hints of what to do and what to avoid.
General Synod 30 In Cleveland, Ohio
2016
April – Annual meeting in Cleveland where we met with UCC leaders (John Dorhauer, Jim Moos,Traci Blackmon, Pension Boards (Brian Bodager, Rick Walters), and UCF (Don Hart and Katie McCloskey). We attempted to develop a 5-year plan, did some visioning, then focused on implementation of 2015 resolution and presence at 2017
Implementation of 2015 resolution
2017 - A General Synod Year
General Synod 31 in Baltimore, Maryland
Summary
Some positive patterns have emerged since 2012
Some items continue to need more attention
2018
Annual meeting in DC, April 17-19 with invited presenters: Yusef Munayyer, USCPR; Leah Muskin-Pierret, USCPR; Loren McGrail, Global Ministries. Two days of goal setting and organizational development, included a new structure with classes and terms for steering
committee members, one day of advocacy on the Hill.
Actions coming out of Annual Meeting:
How Are the Children curriculum:
Other Actions during the year:
2019 – A General Synod Year, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Annual Meeting in DC, April 8-10, 2019: with guest presenters – Peter Makari (by Skype), Brad Parker from Defense of Children International – Palestine (by Skype), Paul Norsi from the Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace (PCAP),the Rev. Mitri Raheb, Leah Muskin Pierret from the US Campaign for Palestinian Rights. Two days of strategizing about the work, resources, and structure of UCC PIN, in the context of (1) current realities in Palestine; (2) the 2015 and 2017 GS resolutions; (3) the launch of How Are the Children?, (4) the upcoming General Synod in Wisconsin. Day 3 we spent on the Hill advocating with Congressional members about Betty McCollum’s soon to be re-introduced bill on the rights of Palestinian children (H.R. 2407).
Actions coming out of the Annual Meeting:
General Synod Presence:
Other Actions during the year:
2020 – the year Covid hit
Actions during this unusual year
•
Secured the requisite six congregations to endorse our resolution, “Declaration for a Just Peace between Palestine and Israel.”
Issued 10 UCC PIN E-NEWS
2021 – General Synod Year, Virtual Synod
Up to General Synod in July, UCC PIN was laser focused on promoting the resolution Declaration for a Just Peace Between Palestine and Israel which which the Committee on Dispositions eventually agreed, after our UCC PIN appeal, to recommend be brought as a resolution of witness to a committee of General Synod (after initially recommending it be referred to an implementation committee of the Board of Directors). PIN’s promotional efforts included:
• Development of packets of education materials to distribute to Conference ministers to introduce delegates and congregations to the resolution, including FAQ document.
• Development of a presentation for the Implementation Workshop, required for all resolutions. Jenny Veninga, Dave Grishaw-Jones, John Thomas, Peter Makari, Allie Perry worked on this, with Ariel Ackermann developing the presentation format and narrating it when presented during the Synod Implementation Committee
• Outreach to congregations to secure endorsements beyond the initial six. We ended up with 15 congregations endorsing the resolution.
• PIN steering committee members created minute long videos speaking to one of the six Resolution affirmations/rejections for
sharing on social media
• Endorsements by Rifat Kassis, Global Kairos for Justice, and human rights lawyer Robert Herbst and Rabbi Brian Walt
•
Synod’s overwhelming adoption of the resolution (83% of the delegates), with the words “sin” and “apartheid” that the vetting committee had taken out restored in the plenary thanks to amendments championed by Dave Grishaw-Jones for the word
‘apartheid’ and Shari Prestemon for the word ‘sin.’
Implementation of Declaration for a Just Peace Between Palestine and Israel
• E-News featured a focus on the 9 spokes of the resolution implementation wheel, one per issue.
• Working with Michael Spath, Indiana Center for Middle East Peace, UCC PIN offered four webinars inspired by the 2021 Synod resolution, the first two offered in the fall of 2021, the third and fourth in early 2022. Topics: (1) The Oppression of Palestinians: It’s a Sin; (2) The Oppression of Palestinians: It’s Apartheidl
Other Actions:
• Elice Higginbotham, with input from Domenic Ackermann began working on the resource “Engaging in Difficult Conversations,”
• Continued promotion of How Are the Children. Newsletter distributed to 650 contacts with 30% open rate and increase in Youtube viewing of the film.
• Endorsement of and advocacy for Rep. Betty McCollum’s bill HR 2590 and then for the new Congress
• Endorsement of and advocacy for the Pillsbury boycott.
• Signed on to letter to Secretary of State Blinken protesting Israel’s criminalization of human rights organizations.
• Elected four new members to our steering committee: Venson Jordan, Barbara Kershner- Daniel, Shari Prestemon, and Andrew Long- Higgins
• Issued 12 UCC PIN E-NEWS
2022
UCC PIN continued to focus on implementation of the 2021 resolution, grappling with the challenges of grassroots organizing: engaging congregations, doing outreach to churches, and reaching people in the pews. We agreed at the start of the year to continue developing resources, specifically focusing on:
Absent the capacity to hold an in-person strategic planning retreat, an ad-hoc planning group (Jeff McElwee, John Thomas, Ariel Ackermann, Barbara Kershner-Daniel, Dave Yoshida, and Allie Perry) considered several options for virtual planning. opted to do a modified, virtual strategic planning process, holding listen sessions with three of our Palestinian partners: Rifat Kassis of Kairos Palestine, Bernard Sabella of the Department of Service to Palestinian Refugees, and Omar Haramy of Sabeel.
These conversations lead our Steering Committee to name three strategic initiatives: (1) Building a UCC Anti-Apartheid Movement; (2) Engaging Young Adults; (3) Interpreting/Education about the Right of Return. After discussion, we decided to move forward on the first through the AFSC organized apartheid-free congregations initiative and our solidarity circle, to table the second for now, and to explore with Michael Spath the possibility of a webinar on the third. Our Palestinian partners urge UCC PIN to keep using the word “apartheid” so that it makes “mainstream.”
Actions:
• Hosted the 3rd on Human Rights-based Approach and the 4th on Christian Zionism webinars in our Implementing the General Synod 4-part Webinar Series, with Michael Spath, ICMEP
• Hosted a webinar on the Weaponization of Anti-Semitism with Mark Weber presenting, Michael Spath facilitating
• Finalized and released the Engaging Difficult Conversations resource
• Co-Sponsored the Easter Community Holy Saturday Service from Jerusalem with Naim Ateek
• Launched a trial Solidarity Circle, facilitated by Eric Fistler and Marla Schrader with eight clergy/congregational leaders over
6 months starting in December 2022
• Joined with representatives from other PIN’s to develop an Apartheid-Free Congregations initiative, convened by AFSC
• Introduced Slack as a new communications platform for UCC PIN to use internally
• Kelly Cox and the Communications Committee started the process of redesigning the PIN website to make it more intuitive and
easier to navigate
• UCC PIN participates in monthly FOSNA-convened denominational PIN calls, Allie represents UCCPIN
• Ariel Ackermann, Dave Grishaw-Jones, Marcia Hoffman, and Martha Koenig-Stone were elected for second three-year terms, along with Shari Prestemon for a 1 year term. Diane Wieble and Philip Farah rotated off the committee.
• Issued 12 UCC PIN E-News.
2023 General Synod Year (Indianapolis, Indiana) and the Assault on Gaza
Organization developments for UCC PIN:
• Redesign of UCC PIN website completed and launched.
• Andrew Long-Higgins joins communications committee (following departure of Diane Wieble who had been our PIN webmeister.
Ariel Ackermann continues to chair the committee. Other members are Dave Yoshida and Allie Perry. Kelly Cox continues as our Digital Communications Manager.
• Conducted PIN’s first $5,000 challenge matching grant appeal, in anticipation of General Synod expenses and raised [amount] towards the $5,000 pledged.
• Welcomed new UCC PIN members: Tala Al Rabeh, the Rev. Edward Davis, the Rev. Rhina Ramos, and the Rev. Lorraine Ceniseros.
(The Rev. Lorraine Ceniseros who had been elected had to resign one month into her term.)
• In recognition of Kelly Cox’s good work and tenure as PIN’s Digital Communications Manager, we voted to increase her hourly rate to $35, from $30.
• Kelly Cox announced her decision to accept a full-time position elsewhere, completing her time with PIN at the end of August; PIN communications committee initiated the search for a new Digital Communications Manager, and selected Nadim Yousef to start as on February 1, 2024
• After reviewing PIN’s support for other organizations, we budgeted these annual donations: $500 each to FOSNA, Apartheid-Free, US Campaign for Palestinian Rights, the Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace, and the Indiana Center for Middle East Peace. $250 for Palestine Portal.
• Steering Committee changes: Shari Prestemon, Eric Fistler, Tala Raheb stepped down. Crystal McCormack-Silva, Stephen Gasteyer, and Elice Higginbotham agreed to serve a second term. New elected were: the Rev. Sara Ofner-Seals and Abad Al-Salam Manasra.
• On-going challenges continue with our current fiscal sponsor. UCCPIN continues to look for an alternative General Synod
• UCCPIN hosted an exhibit booth, staffed by Steering Committee member Elice Higginbotham with assistance from Allie Perry, promoting the Apartheid-Free congregations initiative, providing baklava and hummus, giving out olive wood (custom made in Bethlehem) magnets with UCCPIN’s logo. Lots of visitors. AFSC’s Dov Baum joined us in the booth for two full days of Synod.
• In conjunction with Global Ministries, UCC PIN offered a workshop with AFSC’s Dov Baum presenting on Apartheid-Free Congregations. About 20-25 people attended.
• UCCPIN Steering Committee member Shari Prestemon during a Synod speak out brought to delegates’ attention Israel’s bombing assault on the Jenin refugee camp going on at the same time that Synod had been meeting.
Actions
• Co-sponsored Voices from the Holy Land film series, and were featured as a sponsor for the showing of “The Law and the Prophets.” Crystal McCormack-Silva spoke on PIN’s behalf about work.
• First Solidarity Circle completed in May to positive reviews from participants. Eric Firstler, Susan Switzer, Marla Schrader, Dave Grishaw-Jones, and Allie Perry debrief the experience and decide to continue, offering a next one in the fall of 2024.
• UCC PIN adopts the Apartheid-Free Pledge and promotes it through our E-News. Allie Perry represents UCC PIN on monthly Apartheid-Free calls.
• Co-hosted with Global Ministries the webinar, “Post-Easter Reflections,” with Munther Isaac.
• UCC PIN co-sponsors ICMEP three-part webinar series (post October 7) of successive conversations with Diana Buttu, Philip Farah, and Graylan Hagler
• Appointed a working group to develop a “clergy primer” on the Crisis in Gaza: John Thomas, Elice Higginbotham, Stephen Gasteyer, Dave Yoshida, Venson Jordan, and Allie Perry.
• Issued 13 UCC PIN E-NEWS including a special edition post October 7th. Lists of Contacts tops 500, open rate consistently exceeds 50%
2024 The Gaza Crisis/ Genocide Continues
Organization Developments for UCC PIN:
• Elected two additional steering committee members: the Rev. Thad Winkle and the Rev. Micah Bucey
• Given the geographic spread of steering committee members, we decided to hold all monthly meetings at 1 pm ET on the first Monday of the month (unless there is a holiday when we will meet on the second Monday)
• Appointed an ad-hoc planning committee (Edward Davis, Linda Noonan, Dave Grishaw-Jones, Dave Yoshida, and Allie Perry) to develop a proposal and plan an in-person UCC PIN Strategic Planning Retreat, to be held May 13-15 at the Saint Raphaela Retreat Center in Haverford, PA.
Actions:
• UCCPIN signed on to the South Africa Genocide Convention Case at the International Criminal of Justice.
• Released our UCC PIN Resource, “Crisis in Gaza: Leading Congregations to Understanding and Action.
• Endorsed Gaza Ceasefire Pilgrimage https://www.gazaceasefirepilgrimage.com/